Contact: +86 189 4818 7408 中文
News center
Stay up-to-date on the latest news here.
Home > News > UK sellers, don’t just focus on GMV during the peak season: refund and chargeback rates are quietly eating away at your profits! Return

UK sellers, don’t just focus on GMV during the peak season: refund and chargeback rates are quietly eating away at your profits!
2026-11-18

The peak season surrounding Black Friday and Christmas is a critical period for cross-border sellers in the UK to boost their sales figures. An uptick in traffic, a rise in orders, and strong advertising conversion rates often signal that a store has entered its peak-season rhythm. However, one crucial question is frequently overlooked: as order volume grows, are profits actually increasing as well?

 

If sellers focus solely on Gross Merchandise Value (GMV) and Return on Ad Spend (ROAS), they may fail to notice the costs hidden behind those orders. Expenses such as advertising outlays, product refunds, payment chargebacks, fulfillment costs, and the processing of returned items can steadily erode actual profit margins.

 

A recent analysis of the UK retail sector during the peak season serves as a reminder: an increase in traffic does not equate to genuine, profitable demand, and a rise in order volume does not necessarily mean an increase in profit. For sellers operating in the UK market, it is not enough to focus exclusively on sales revenue; factors like refund rates and chargeback rates must also be integrated into daily profit calculations.

 

IMRG Warns: Peak-Season Traffic Growth May Mask Real Losses

 

According to a report by Niceggie on November 15—summarizing an analysis of the UK retail sector released by IMRG on November 13—retailers are cautioned against relying solely on website traffic, ad clicks, and order growth to gauge their business performance.

 

One notable statistic highlights that for a retailer with an annual turnover of approximately £100 million, a 5% fraud rate could translate into potential annual losses of nearly £1 million. This estimate serves as a stark reminder that as the scale of transactions grows, so too can the associated operational risks.

 

For cross-border sellers, the peak season can bring a complex mix of outcomes: advertising spend may rise, but so does the cost of customer acquisition; order volume may increase, yet a portion of those orders may ultimately result in refunds; and while sales figures may look impressive, profits can be squeezed by chargebacks, fulfillment expenses, and the costs of handling returns.

 

Consequently, sellers must look beyond the simple question of "how much was sold." They need to dig deeper: Which orders are truly generating revenue? Which products remain profitable after all costs are deducted? And which SKUs—despite appearing to be best-sellers—are actually draining the business's bottom line? The refund rate is not merely a post-sales metric; it also impacts advertising performance and product profitability.

 

Many sellers delegate the monitoring of refund rates to their customer service or after-sales teams, while leaving the analysis of advertising return on ad spend (ROAS) to their operations staff. In practice, however, these metrics are deeply interconnected.

 

First, refunds directly affect a product’s actual revenue. When a customer returns an item, the seller may incur costs related to the refund amount itself, return shipping, product inspection, and subsequent processing. If a returned item is damaged or otherwise unsuitable for resale, it may also result in inventory loss.

 

Second, the refund rate influences the true effectiveness of advertising campaigns. A product might generate a high volume of orders through advertising—showing strong sales figures and a healthy ROAS in the backend—but if a significant portion of those orders are ultimately returned, the effective revenue generated by the ads will be lower than the headline numbers suggest. If sellers evaluate advertising performance solely based on initial order value, they risk continuing to allocate budget to SKUs that actually yield low or negative profit.

 

Furthermore, the chargeback rate warrants separate attention. A chargeback—where a consumer initiates a transaction dispute through their payment provider—is distinct from a standard return or refund. Chargebacks can lead to financial losses, the burden of managing disputes, and additional fees; therefore, they should not be lumped together with routine refunds.

 

This is why, when calculating profitability during peak seasons, sellers should not look exclusively at sales revenue and advertising spend. Instead, they must analyze refund rates, chargeback rates, and fulfillment costs in tandem. Only then can a seller gain a clear picture of the true operational performance of each product.

 

For sellers in the UK market, the rise of paid returns is a trend to watch—but what happens to the products once they are returned?

 

The landscape for return policies in the UK is shifting. According to peak-season data from ZigZag, the proportion of its retail partners offering paid return options has grown from 54% in 2024 to 59% in 2026. Paid returns are projected to account for 43% of the total return volume across its network, up from 40% in 2025.

 

This indicates that an increasing number of retailers are shifting a portion of return-related costs onto consumers to alleviate the financial strain of reverse logistics. However, for sellers, charging consumers for returns does not mean that the costs associated with returns simply disappear. Once products are returned, sellers must still handle tasks such as receiving, inspecting, categorizing, and managing subsequent inventory. This is particularly true for apparel, footwear, and headwear, which may arrive with stains, creases, damaged packaging, missing tags, or signs of wear. The condition of each returned item dictates how it should be processed and determines its residual value.

 

If returned items remain uninspected and uncategorized for an extended period, sellers struggle to promptly determine which products can be resold, which require further processing, and which are no longer suitable for sale. The longer items sit in the warehouse, the greater the pressure on inventory management and the higher the risk of value depreciation.

 

Therefore, when developing return strategies for the peak season, UK-based sellers must look beyond whether consumers should bear the cost of returns; they must also proactively plan the inspection and processing workflows for returned goods.

 

UK-based sellers should create a peak-season profit report at the SKU level.

 

To accurately gauge profitability during the peak season, sellers need to break down operational data from the store level to the individual SKU level. The analytical framework proposed by IMRG offers a useful guide: it allows sellers to evaluate advertising costs, conversion rates, refund rates, chargeback rates, fulfillment costs, and contribution margins within a single, unified report.

 

Specifically, each SKU should track the following data categories:

 

- Sales Performance: Actual sales revenue, units sold, and conversion rates—to determine if a product is generating genuine, effective sales.

- Marketing Costs: Advertising spend, orders generated via advertising, and return on ad spend (ROAS)—to assess whether the cost of customer acquisition is reasonable.

- Refunds and Risks: Number of refunds, refund rates, number of chargebacks, and chargeback rates—to identify the losses underlying the reported sales revenue.

- Fulfillment and Return Costs: Product costs, platform fees, logistics expenses, and the costs associated with return shipping and processing—to calculate the total actual expenditure incurred during the sales process.

- Final Profitability: By synthesizing the data above, calculate the contribution margin for each SKU to determine whether the product is truly generating profit for the store.

 

For instance, a specific apparel item might see high sales volume during Black Friday, but if it requires significant advertising investment and carries a refund rate notably higher than other products in the store, its actual profitability may be questionable. On the surface, a product might appear to be a best-seller during the peak season; however, once costs—such as advertising, refunds, and return processing—are deducted, its gross profit contribution may be quite low. In such cases, sellers need to re-evaluate their promotional intensity and operational strategy for that item.

 

By utilizing SKU-level reports, sellers can more quickly identify products with excessive advertising costs, unusually high refund rates, or significant losses from returns. This allows for timely adjustments to advertising spend, optimization of product detail pages, or improvements to sizing information and quality control.

 

Prompt inspection of returned items is essential to minimizing profit loss.

 

Creating profit reports serves a purpose beyond post-peak-season reviews; more importantly, it helps sellers pinpoint operational areas in need of improvement. The handling of returned items is one such area that is frequently overlooked.

 

For sellers in the UK market, promptly receiving, inspecting, and categorizing returned goods locally allows for a clearer understanding of their actual condition, facilitating informed decisions on how to handle them moving forward. For eligible items—such as apparel, footwear, and headwear—services like steaming, tidying, and folding can be performed, preparing the products for resale or other disposition methods.

 

For instance, U-Speed’s UK return warehouse offers services including local receipt of returns, quality inspections, and specialized processing (such as steaming or organizing) for apparel and footwear. This helps sellers stay informed about the status of returned inventory, reducing the management burden caused by items sitting in limbo for long periods.

 

Of course, not all returned items can be resold. The true value lies in timely inspection and categorization, which clarifies whether an item remains usable, how it should be processed, and the extent of any potential inventory loss. This enables more accurate calculation of return-related costs while preserving as much of the product's residual value as possible.

 

Competition during the UK peak season is not just about traffic and order volume; it is also a contest of cost control and profit management. While GMV growth is important, failing to effectively manage refund rates, chargebacks, and fulfillment costs can mean that higher order volumes actually lead to greater operational pressure.

 

For cross-border sellers in the UK, it is highly advisable to begin generating SKU-level profit reports during the peak season—consolidating advertising, refunds, chargebacks, and fulfillment costs into a single, comprehensive analysis. At the same time, plan ahead for the local inspection and subsequent processing of returned items.