Contact: +86 189 4818 7408 中文
News center
Stay up-to-date on the latest news here.
Home > News > Black Friday sales may be up, but profits might not follow—cross-border sellers shouldn't overlook the cost of returns! Return

Black Friday sales may be up, but profits might not follow—cross-border sellers shouldn't overlook the cost of returns!
2026-11-18

For cross-border sellers, the most critical metrics to monitor during the Black Friday peak season often extend well beyond total sales revenue. Does an increase in revenue necessarily mean a higher volume of goods sold? And while order figures may look impressive, how much profit actually remains after accounting for discounts, advertising costs, and returns?

 

A notable trend this peak season is the potential for a significant gap between growth in sales revenue and growth in the actual volume of units sold. If sellers rely solely on Gross Merchandise Value (GMV) to gauge their performance, they risk overestimating their true sales volume—while simultaneously underestimating the profit-eroding impact of subsequent product returns.

 

Consequently, beyond tracking orders and revenue, sellers must carefully evaluate the actual number of units sold, the profit margin per item, and the costs associated with processing returns once the peak season concludes.

 

A 5%–10% increase in revenue could translate to only 2%–3% growth in actual unit sales.

 

According to an interview with Kraig Foreman, President of E-commerce for DHL Supply Chain, published by FreightWaves on November 16, holiday season sales (in dollar terms) are projected to grow by 5%–10%. However, once factors such as price increases are stripped away, the actual volume of goods sold may only grow by 2%–3%. This suggests that the rise in revenue is not entirely driven by consumers purchasing a larger quantity of products.

 

Looking at the U.S. e-commerce market as a whole, growth is still anticipated. Adobe forecasts that U.S. online holiday sales—covering the period from November 1 to December 31—will reach $275.1 billion, a 6.7% year-over-year increase. Within this, Cyber Monday sales are expected to hit $12.9 billion, up 9.2% from the previous year. It is important to note, however, that these figures represent monetary value rather than the actual number of units sold.

 

Another shift lies in how consumers compare prices. DHL notes that approximately 90% of online shoppers this year are expected to leverage AI-powered tools to hunt for better deals and promotions. As consumers find it increasingly easy to compare prices across different platforms and sellers, those attempting to secure orders through simple price cuts may face even fiercer competition.

 

For cross-border sellers, these data points serve as a clear signal: while peak-season revenue may appear to be on the rise, the growth in actual unit sales may not be as robust as it seems. Relying solely on Gross Merchandise Value (GMV) to gauge Black Friday performance often overlooks critical nuances—such as the interplay between pricing, discount levels, and the actual volume of units sold.

 

Just because sales revenue grows, it doesn’t mean the costs associated with returns will scale down proportionally.

 

The relationship between sales revenue and returns is not a simple, direct correlation. The actual volume of returns—and the subsequent costs of handling them—are driven by factors such as the number of units sold, product category characteristics, consumer expectations, and the inherent quality or suitability of the items themselves.

 

For instance, consider a seller who generates $40,000 in Black Friday sales. This could represent 1,000 units sold at $40 each, or a smaller number of units sold at a higher price point. While the total revenue is the same, the number of orders, the actual volume of goods shipped, and the potential number of returns differ significantly.

 

Focusing exclusively on revenue makes it difficult for sellers to accurately estimate the volume of returns they will need to process once the peak season concludes. This is especially true for categories like apparel and footwear, where issues such as incorrect sizing, discrepancies in color, or a gap between the product and the customer’s expectations frequently lead to returns.

 

Furthermore, aggressive discounting can further compress profit margins. To boost conversion rates during Black Friday, sellers often deepen discounts or increase advertising spend to capture traffic. However, while the selling price drops, the costs associated with warehousing, logistics, return inspection, and restocking do not decrease accordingly.

 

When a return occurs, sellers face not only the cost of issuing a refund but also expenses related to return shipping, warehouse receiving, product inspection, repackaging, and final disposition. If an item cannot be resold, it may also result in an additional inventory loss.

 

Therefore, the true focus during a peak season should not just be on the total dollar value of sales, but on the actual profit retained from each individual unit sold.

The same GMV can yield vastly different profit outcomes.

 

For cross-border sellers, it is essential to break down Black Friday sales data further—specifically by looking at the number of units sold and the profit margin per item.

 

Suppose two different stores both generate $40,000 in Black Friday sales... Store A sells 1,000 units at $40 each, utilizing a larger discount; Store B, with a smaller discount, sells 950 units at approximately $42.10 each. While their total sales revenue is roughly the same, the actual number of units sold differs.

 

If both stores have a 10% return rate, Store A would see 100 returns, while Store B would see 95. Assuming it costs $8 to inspect and process each returned item, Store A incurs $40 more in return-handling costs than Store B.

 

This is a simplified example—it does not reflect industry-average return rates or actual processing costs—but it illustrates a key point: even when Gross Merchandise Value (GMV) is identical, variations in unit volume, discount levels, and return rates lead to different final profit outcomes.

 

In real-world operations, one must also account for factors such as product procurement costs, advertising spend, platform commissions, logistics fees, and whether returned items can be resold. For products with deep discounts and inherently low margins per unit, a single return can significantly erode already slim profits.

 

Therefore, sellers should not merely look at total sales revenue or order volume after a peak season. Instead, they should implement a more granular profit-accounting method: track actual units sold, transaction prices, per-unit gross margins, and return rates—broken down by SKU—and factor in return-handling costs to determine which products are truly contributing to the store’s bottom line.

 

For the Black Friday peak season, sellers should make three key preparations in advance:

 

First, calculate true profit at the SKU level. Do not rely solely on the store’s overall GMV; instead, analyze the actual transaction price, unit volume, and profit margin for each individual product. Pay close attention to items with deep discounts, high return rates, or thin profit margins. Even if an SKU performs well in terms of sales volume, if it yields little to no profit after accounting for advertising, logistics, and return costs, its promotional strategy should be re-evaluated.

 

Second, continuously monitor return activity for key product categories. The reasons for returns—and the complexity of handling them—vary significantly across different product categories. For apparel, sellers should pay close attention to sizing, style, and product condition; for electronics, they should watch for functional defects, missing accessories, and physical damage. By analyzing historical data and performance during previous peak seasons, sellers can categorize key SKUs and estimate potential return volumes and the resulting operational burden.

 

Third, sellers should develop a plan for handling returns after the peak season. Returns often continue even after the Black Friday and Christmas rush has subsided. If returned items remain in the warehouse for too long, sellers may lose visibility into their inventory status and miss opportunities to restock, resell, or otherwise dispose of the items.

 

For sellers targeting the U.S. market, establishing local return-handling channels can significantly reduce the time and communication costs associated with cross-border returns. Services like the U-Speed US return warehouse, for instance, allow sellers to receive returns locally, inspect items, take photographs, and categorize them. This enables sellers to quickly assess the actual condition of returned goods and determine the appropriate next steps.

 

The value of this approach extends beyond simply receiving returns; it provides sellers with timely insight into their returned inventory, informing decisions on resale or other disposal methods and minimizing the loss in value that occurs when products sit idle for long periods.

 

Looking ahead to the 2026 Black Friday peak season, while growth in sales revenue is anticipated, it does not necessarily equate to a proportional increase in actual unit sales. DHL’s forecast—projecting a 5%–10% increase in sales revenue against only a 2%–3% rise in actual unit volume—serves as a reminder that sellers should not rely solely on Gross Merchandise Value (GMV) to gauge their peak-season performance.

 

For cross-border sellers, what truly matters is the final profit retained after a sale, as well as the value that can be recovered when a product is returned. Shifting focus from total sales revenue to actual unit sales, from order growth to per-item profitability, and proactively planning for return processing and inventory recovery—these are the keys to safeguarding profit margins amidst the intense competition of the peak season.